Uh oh…

So (insert appropriate journalistic disclaimer stating that it only might have happened and that this is just a report from some other news organization that is quoting anonymous sources and this hasn’t been confirmed by the player and in truth, the matter is an open investigation and all the facts aren’t out yet so we shouldn’t jump to conclusions) A-Rod* used steroids.

Let the great debate begin now: A-Roid or A-Fraud?  Looks like the 2009 season has its first subplot, and pitchers and catchers haven’t even reported yet.

With all the hand-wringing that went on in the wake of Barry Bonds* breaking the home run record, there was always the thought that it was going to be OK.  The great hope was that the re-incarnation of Joe DiMaggio himself, in the form of Alex Rodriguez*, would be by in a few years to snatch the record away from Bonds*.  At that point, as a culture, we wouldn’t have to worry about the fact that one of the highest places in the cultural pantheon was taken up by a cheater.  Oops… we did it again.

Here’s to hoping that Albert Pujols hits about 200 home runs this upcoming season… just so people don’t have to worry.

My guess is that there will be no shortage of analysis as to what this “means” for baseball, whether A-Rod* is still a first-ballot Hall of Famer, whether he really “deserves” those MVP trophies, and whether Congress, which apparently has nothing else to do, should investigate the role of steroids in baseball… again.  (Aren’t we at war?)  Maybe what we need to do is stop confusing athletic performance with manly virtue?  Baseball players are little more than men, and men are not angels. 

Here’s what gets me though with A-Rod*.  Consider for a moment that last year, there were questions as to whether A-Rod* was having an affair with Madonna.  Like the steroid allegations, it is yet to be proven.  At the time though, no one questioned whether having an affair would bring his HOF credentials into question.  But, the steroid issue apparently does?

Advertisements

6 Responses to Uh oh…

  1. I’m with you, PC. The thing that gets me is the baseball writers (ex. B.Olney) who instantly see a report and treat it as gospel truth. I can see why they do it, but it still bothers me the lack of logic that they use. If anything, the revelation that A-Rod possibly used steriods, while indeed a questionable moral decision, should just confirm that the mid-to-late 1990s and early 2000s just needs to be treated like we treat the Dead Ball Era: baseball was a different game for a few reasons, and thus we make HOF assessments accordingly. Unfortunately, it’s up to the pontiffs in the BBWAA, not me.

  2. bheikoop says:

    An asterisk? Isn’t it becoming more and more obviously that essentially EVERY player was on juice? This would be like putting a strike through players pre and post mound adjustments. Or pre and post racial segregation.
    That is to say I had some understanding of the Bonds asterisk of a few years back. Back when it was simply speculation regarding the amount of players who were using. But as the years pass and more and more players are being found to have used, it seems as though it was actually a level playing field.

  3. NLMcMullen says:

    There’s a difference between cheating on your wife and cheating at baseball. He broke the rules to win. Pete Rose was banned for less.

  4. Pizza Cutter says:

    I’ll check in with my wife on that one.

  5. Brandon H says:

    Broke the rules of baseball? Where in the rules of baseball did it say, ‘cannot do steroids or other illegal narcotics’?

  6. Dan Novick says:

    Brandon–
    It 100% was illegal, there is no disputing that. There was just no punishment for it at the time. Baseball has always had a rule saying that players must have prescriptions for non-OTC medicines, but in the CBA at the time, it was explicitly stated that steroids were illegal.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: